Your SEO optimized title

Create a box - Up to 8 selections

(181 reviews) Write a Review
Calculated at Checkout

Mrs Cavanaugh's "create a box" is the easiest way to customize your own box, filled with chocolates you love the most! The hardest part will be deciding between the dozens of caramels, creams, clusters, truffles and specialty chocolates in milk chocolate or dark chocolate. Choose between 1 and 8 different chocolates by selecting from the drop-down options (if you desire less than 8 different chocolates, leave the remaining selections at "None"). The box will be evenly split among your choices. Depending on the variety, there are approximately 18-26 chocolates per pound.

To see our complete list of available chocolates, please Click Here


181 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Awesome chocolate!

    Posted by Zariell Oldfield on 25th May 2020

    Get it within a week of ordering and it’s awesome to pick a chocolate out of the box and not have to worry if you’ll like it or not!

  • 5
    Create a Box

    Posted by Margaret Zalac Krivickas on 22nd May 2020

    I bought a box of assorted chocolates before and these 8 were my favorites. I have bought Fannie May for years and I prefer yours now that I have tried it.

  • 5
    Choice box

    Posted by Nancy Zolman on 22nd May 2020

    Fast shipping. Packed in a cool box. Incredibly delicious. Large pieces. Very creamy & rich chocolates.

  • 5
    Create a box

    Posted by Valerie Metzner on 22nd May 2020

    This candy now ranks as one of my all time favs! I picked out all of my favorites and none disappointed. The milk chocolate was creamy and the various fillings were quite tasty. When I am next in Utah, soon I hope, I'll be sure to stop by and get more.

  • 3

    Posted by Barbara Davison on 21st May 2020


  • 5
    Best Assortment

    Posted by Bkupfer on 21st May 2020

    Love the option to choose the assortment you want and the shipping is excellent!

  • 5
    Great Chocolate

    Posted by Carolyn Hutchinson on 21st May 2020

    Loving the variety and taste is very good.

  • 5
    Enjoying the chocolate selection

    Posted by Denise Marcus on 20th May 2020

    Thank you for letting me select the chocolates in my box. All are delicious. I am really enjoying the chocolate covered Brazil nuts , which seem to be unique to your shop. All the chocolates are yummy

  • 4
    create a box

    Posted by Unknown on 20th May 2020

    My mom enjoyed these chocolates! Marshmallows excellent and a varied selection. Thanks!

  • 5
    2 lb box creams

    Posted by Joanne Brenna on 19th May 2020

    Having moved to Colorado from Bountiful, I've missed Mrs. Cavanaughs. I realized I could have it delivered! I send to others for gifts also. They are always appreciated. The candy is way above Sees and Godiva. They are delivered in perfect condition. No melted chocolate.