null Your SEO optimized title

Create a box - Up to 8 selections

(453 reviews) Write a Review
Calculated at Checkout

Mrs Cavanaugh's "create a box" is the easiest way to customize your own box, filled with chocolates you love the most! The hardest part will be deciding between the dozens of caramels, creams, clusters, truffles and specialty chocolates in milk chocolate or dark chocolate. Choose between 1 and 8 different chocolates by selecting from the drop-down options (if you desire less than 8 different chocolates, leave the remaining selections at "None"). The box will be evenly split among your choices. Depending on the variety, there are approximately 18-26 chocolates per pound.

To see our complete list of available chocolates, please Click Here


453 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Milk chocolate creams

    Posted by Leanne Alexander on 4th Nov 2023

    My favorite flavors were lemon, orange, raspberry, and vanilla. I love that there’s orange and lemon zest in the creams, and the vanilla one was especially creamy. These are outstanding creams!

  • 5
    Build a box

    Posted by Tina Riddle on 7th Oct 2023

    So delicious and I can pick my favorites!!

  • 5
    Best Chocolates Ever!

    Posted by Robin Greeley on 25th Sep 2023

    These are the best chocolates we have ever had the pleasure of eating! Excellent quality chocolate with extremely generous amount of dipping. The fillings are so heavenly delicious it’s hard to pick only 8 flavors for the Create-a-Box! But somehow I do it and we’re always satisfied until it’s time to find an excuse to order more!

  • 5

    Posted by Susan Lukachko on 21st Sep 2023

    Perfectly delicious!

  • 5
    Delicious and best value

    Posted by Arch Woodside on 14th Sep 2023

    Very much like the home made candies that my mom made when I was growing up in Pittsburgh. Delicious and best value = Mrs. Cavanaugh's. My wife has 3 birthdays each year so I may give her 2lbs of Mrs. C personally selected 8 choices--she even gets to eat some of the candy.

  • 5
    I loved my candy

    Posted by Madeline Ann Bush on 9th Sep 2023

    I am very impressed with this company. They am to please and will correct their mistake if your not happy. I have ordered about 5 or 6 boxes of candy from them in the past several months. Only 1 time it was messed up. I told them and reordered a new box of candy ,they gave it to me for free. Thank you!

  • 5
    Create a box

    Posted by Carolyn Wheeler on 26th Aug 2023

    The best chocolate! I love the dark chocolate nuts and truffles!

  • 5

    Posted by Megan Rands on 20th Aug 2023

    Always my go to! It’s been my favorite for over 35 years and I love the quality of the chocolate and they were delivered fast and chilled so just as wonderful as if I had picked it up myself. I don’t live close to one of the locations so I love I can get them whenever I want. ?

  • 5

    Posted by Marieanne Boyer on 17th Aug 2023

    The candy was very good! I will get it again.

  • 5

    Posted by Mary Wood on 29th Jul 2023

    I have been addicted to Mrs. Cavanaugh's chocolates for literally decades. I used to live in Utah and bought them in a Mrs. Cavanaugh's store. Now that I live in Ohio, I buy them online. Love them!