null Your SEO optimized title

Create a box - Up to 8 selections

(409 reviews) Write a Review
Calculated at Checkout

Mrs Cavanaugh's "create a box" is the easiest way to customize your own box, filled with chocolates you love the most! The hardest part will be deciding between the dozens of caramels, creams, clusters, truffles and specialty chocolates in milk chocolate or dark chocolate. Choose between 1 and 8 different chocolates by selecting from the drop-down options (if you desire less than 8 different chocolates, leave the remaining selections at "None"). The box will be evenly split among your choices. Depending on the variety, there are approximately 18-26 chocolates per pound.

To see our complete list of available chocolates, please Click Here


409 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Excellent Chocolates

    Posted by Flournoy Gardner Jr on 25th Aug 2022

    This was my first purchase and I was not disappointed. The selection, the flavors everything was amazing. I will definitely be ordering again.

  • 5
    Best chocolate ever!

    Posted by Emily on 22nd Jul 2022

    I love the opportunity to select exactly which chocolate I want. It is delicious and I highly recommend it.

  • 5
    Boxed Chocolates

    Posted by Mark Tucker on 21st Jul 2022

    Wife and I were very satisfied with our purchase. I especially fell in love with the orange creams. My absolute favorite. She loves the Trinidads. Thank you.

  • 5
    Chocolate pick your own box

    Posted by Sherry Wiseman on 8th Jul 2022


  • 5
    Assortment of 8 Choices

    Posted by Joseph E Steckelberg on 23rd Jun 2022

    Great ****************

  • 4
    Custom chocolate box Father's Day

    Posted by Cathy Uchida on 22nd Jun 2022

    The candy was delicious. It was shipped to TN during periods of 95-100 degree heat. FedEx delivery was delayed by 1 day so we were concerned about the state of the individual pieces upon arrival. The blue ice was not cool, but the candy was intact. I'm looking forward to our next order (maybe in Fall or Winter instead of summer).

  • 5
    The best chocolate in the world!

    Posted by Angie Knight on 19th May 2022

    I love that we can pick our favorites to make up our box of the most delicious chocolates in the world.

  • 5
    mixed candy box

    Posted by Donna Moss on 18th May 2022

    every time I order, it comes promptly, packaged extremely well and is the finest candy I've ever eaten!

  • 5
    Perfect gift

    Posted by Lauren R MacArthur on 15th May 2022

    These were delivered to my granddaughter, who lives outside Salt Lake, as a Mother's Day remembrance. The delivery time was perfect, and the chocolates, she said, are "Wonderful!" Since I live in Maine, I depended upon two things...that the chocolates be delicious, and the delivery on time. Thank you for taking care of this for me!!!

  • 4
    2lb Select Chocolates - Assortments

    Posted by Deirdre Hollins on 28th Apr 2022

    The chocolates are good (lets get that out of the way)! The issue is, when you buy more than one pound, the same chocolates are put into each box, when you should be able to add chocolates to each box, and THEN combine them. I wanted one pound of 1 single candy, but was unable to get it like that because the samples I choose for 1 pound, automatically became the same for the second pound. I shouldn't have to place 2 separate orders to get what I wanted. I'll probably not order again, as I can go into a chocolatier and put my (pounds) together EXACTLY how I want. We are disappointed that you weren't completely satisfied. In the future, please specify this desire in order notes and we will do our best to accommodate. As you stated, you can also add each box separately, which will solve the issue. -Mrs. Cavanaugh's Chocolates and Ice Cream