Create a box - Up to 8 selections - Mrs. Cavanaugh's Chocolates & Ice Cream

Description
593 Reviews

Custom Assortment Of Chocolates

Mrs. Cavanaugh's "Create a Box" makes it easy to customize your own chocolate box filled with your favorite treats! The toughest decision? Choosing from a tempting assortment of caramels, creams, clusters, truffles, and specialty chocolates, available in both milk and dark chocolate. Select between 1 and 8 different chocolates using the drop-down menu—if you prefer fewer than 8, simply leave the remaining options set to "None." Your box will be evenly divided among your selections, with approximately 18-26 chocolates per pound, depending on the variety. Perfect for gifting or indulging in your personal favorites!

Chocolate Box Options

View our chocolate options available with this unique box. From rich and chewy caramels like the Caramel, Almond Chocolate Dipped Gregory and Caramel, Sea Salt to creamy delights like Crème Raspberry Lemonade and Crème Key Lime, the options are endless. Nut lovers will enjoy classics like Cluster Almond or Caramel Pecan (Cavalier), while fans of unique flavors can try treats like French Mint Crème or the layered Opera Crème with chocolate, vanilla, and raspberry. Many varieties are available in milk, dark, and even white chocolate, ensuring there's something for everyone in your custom box.

593 Reviews

5
Very delicious!

Posted by Onteaka Scott on 27th Jul 2026

My husband gave me a box for Mother’s Day. Then I liked it so much, that I bought my own box, this time.
5
Some of the best chocolate I’ve had

Posted by Krista Boston on 11th Jul 2026

I buy chocolate regularly for my mother who lives with me and she is a chocolate fiend. Our go to has been an international company but I saw the ad for Mrs Cavanaugh on Facebook and decided a USA made purchase was a better approach for us and decided to try it. We were exceptionally pleased with the quality shipping. service and just general process of ordering and receiving. She loves it and hoards a box in her room even. The chocolates are fantastic - we chose all caramel style and it’s all terrific. Just the right size too. Big enough for these chocolate lovers. But not too much. Thanks Mrs Cavanaugh for sharing your story as a business and giving us a chance to try it as a result.
5
Create A Box

Posted by Denise on 11th Jul 2026

I loved all of the chocolates!! I ordered all dark chocolate!
5
Create a box dark/milk chocolate mix

Posted by Ann Kochenberger on 6th Jul 2026

This is a thank you gift to a medical center. Sending your chocolate ensures me that not only will they love the chocolate, but that they will also love the BEST chocolate.
5
Creature on assortment

Posted by Cheryl Kisner on 28th Jun 2026

I love the milk, chocolate fruit creams without nuts. They are my favorite and Mrs. Cavanagh Chocolates.
5
Create a box

Posted by Kimberly Levandowski on 28th Jun 2026

I sent them as a thank you to the nurses who had taken care of my mom during her time on hospice and they loved it. They both said that it is the best chocolates that they had ever tasted. I ordered a box for myself before I sent any as a gift so I know they are not lying. It IS the best. So I wanted to send the very best to the people who gave their very best during a time that was very difficult for my family. So thank you Mrs. Cavanaugh for making the chocolate experience the very best, all around.
5
Gift for my husband

Posted by Johanna Riley on 27th Jun 2026

The chocolate was so creamy and delicious, he loved it!
5
1# box with 8 selections

Posted by John F Butterfield on 24th Jun 2026

You are the only place I have found where I can get my favorite chocolates. They are excellent.
5
Create your own collection

Posted by Margaret White on 13th Jun 2026

Absolutely divine, delicious, and more please!
5
Boxed Chocoltes

Posted by Doug Forsha on 2nd Jun 2026

For years I purchased the main SLC competitors boxed chocolates, (founded in 1924). I was surprised to find that Mrs. Cavanaugh's were not only superior in flavor and craftsmanship, but were considerably lower in price. Thank you for your excellence!