Create a box - Up to 8 selections - Mrs. Cavanaugh's Chocolates & Ice Cream

Description
594 Reviews

Custom Assortment Of Chocolates

Mrs. Cavanaugh's "Create a Box" makes it easy to customize your own chocolate box filled with your favorite treats! The toughest decision? Choosing from a tempting assortment of caramels, creams, clusters, truffles, and specialty chocolates, available in both milk and dark chocolate. Select between 1 and 8 different chocolates using the drop-down menu—if you prefer fewer than 8, simply leave the remaining options set to "None." Your box will be evenly divided among your selections, with approximately 18-26 chocolates per pound, depending on the variety. Perfect for gifting or indulging in your personal favorites!

Chocolate Box Options

View our chocolate options available with this unique box. From rich and chewy caramels like the Caramel, Almond Chocolate Dipped Gregory and Caramel, Sea Salt to creamy delights like Crème Raspberry Lemonade and Crème Key Lime, the options are endless. Nut lovers will enjoy classics like Cluster Almond or Caramel Pecan (Cavalier), while fans of unique flavors can try treats like French Mint Crème or the layered Opera Crème with chocolate, vanilla, and raspberry. Many varieties are available in milk, dark, and even white chocolate, ensuring there's something for everyone in your custom box.

594 Reviews

5
Assorted Dark

Posted by Rubén Garza on 18th Apr 2026

DELICIOUS!
5
Assorted Dark Chocolates

Posted by Rubén Garza on 11th Apr 2026

THE BEST EVERY EASTER! THANK YOU!
5
Fantastic fresh and free gift wrap with fst shipping

Posted by Ledra on 7th Apr 2026

I love that I have the option to customize each box that I order at know additional fees. Since I know everyone favorite flavors I get then exactly what they love and nothing is wasted with every single piece being eaten. I also love the fact that you can choose dark or milk chocolate. Fast shipping and packaged with a cold pack to keep chocolates from melting. I love you guys and so does my entire family.
5
Mighty good

Posted by Robert R on 5th Apr 2026

Mighty tasty!
5
BUILD A BOX

Posted by Peri LYNN Stitzel on 6th Mar 2026

WHAT A DELICIOUS IDEA, TO BUILD THE PERFECT BOX, FILLED WITH SPECIAL FAVORITES THAT NOT CANDONLY TICKLE THE TONGUE, BUT ARE TUNIQUELY SATISFYING TO THE PALATE. NO CANDY THAT IS NOT PERSONALLY SATISFYING, EACH BITE IS FILLED WITH ONLY THE BEST MRS. C. HAS TO OFFER.
5
Awesome

Posted by John Johnson on 4th Mar 2026

I have to say that the milk chocolate is easily the best I have ever had. and the multitude of choices is great will get again.
5
Candy order

Posted by Sue on 4th Mar 2026

We visited Salt Lake in September and just happened to stop into Mrs. Cavanaughs and we immediately became hooked! The quality is outstanding. We are from Chicago where Fannie May has been a long time staple - your chocolate completely outdoes Fannie May. We are visiting SLC again in a couple of weeks and we plant on stocking up!! We couldn’t love your candy more- it’s a real treat.
5
Creat a box

Posted by John and Peri STITZEL on 1st Mar 2026

So nice to pick the flavors that are most appealing! The candy is delicious, like fine ambrosia on clouds
5
The Best Chocolate

Posted by Jennifer Jones-Edwards on 21st Feb 2026

I have eaten tons of chocolate. I love chocolate. I have ordered from many different companies and tasted their chocolate. I keep ordering from Mrs. Cavanaughs because their products are delicious. I selected the chocolates for this box for my Mom. I picked her favorites. She loved her box of chocolate.
5
Create a Box

Posted by Priscilla M. on 20th Feb 2026

Create a Box is my favorite item Mrs. Cavanaughs sells. I love that you can choose the type of chocolate you like best and your favorite candy, not to mention you can make up to 8 choices per box. The candies are always fresh and delicious with each wrapper filled to the brim. Mrs. Cavanaugh's make a fantastic product and has become my absolute favorite company to buy candy from. They are truly the best!