Your SEO optimized title

Create a box - Up to 8 selections

(88 reviews) Write a Review
Calculated at Checkout

Mrs Cavanaugh's "create a box" is the easiest way to customize your own box, filled with chocolates you love the most! The hardest part will be deciding between the dozens of caramels, creams, clusters, truffles and specialty chocolates in milk chocolate or dark chocolate. Choose between 1 and 8 different chocolates by selecting from the drop-down options (if you desire less than 8 different chocolates, leave the remaining selections at "None"). The box will be evenly split among your choices. Depending on the variety, there are approximately 18-26 chocolates per pound.

To see our complete list of available chocolates, please Click Here


88 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    I ordered 8 choices.

    Posted by Nancy Jensen on 12th Mar 2019

    I wanted to try many different kinds. They were all good. I loved the marzipan and raspberry cream in particular. The mint in green paper was also excellent, as well as the toffee! I got everything in milk chocolate.

  • 5
    Create your own box

    Posted by Pam Muncy on 26th Feb 2019

    I thiught this candy I selected was delicious. I want to try some more

  • 5

    Posted by Sheila Ward on 19th Feb 2019

    I ordered 5 pounds of various nut cluster chocolates and the Mindy Mint and Chocolate Truffles. They arrived on time, in perfect condition, and were beautifully packaged. These are the finest, melt in your mouth chocolates I have ever tried and I’ve purchased Fannie Mae, Sees, Godiva and Frango Mints. These chocolates put these others to shame. The nuts are so fresh and so tasty, especially when smothered in this creamy, delicious chocolate that, thank God, is not overly sweet. I am so impressed. These chocolates will be a real hit if you’re considering sending a gift to anyone, especially out-of-state friends and relatives! Sensational!

  • 5
    quality of product

    Posted by JoAnn Friedrich on 19th Feb 2019

    wonderful quality and a great idea to be able to pick what you want, Love that! Loved everything!

  • 5

    Posted by TD on 18th Feb 2019

    These thickly-covered chocolates are so smooth and the "mouth-feel" is wonderful. They arrived only 4 days after my order, well-packaged and picture-perfect. Nothing was melted - even down here in the South. As I mentioned before, Ms. C's will absolutely give the other guys a run for their money!

  • 5
    Very good!

    Posted by Hef2793 on 16th Feb 2019

    I was hesitant because I’d never heard of Mrs. Cavanaughs, but after reading reviews, I decided to order. Everything was packaged well and was very good and fresh! The coconut/caramel pieces were my favorite - wish I had more! The least favorite, but still good, were the peanut butter pieces - this is unusual for me because I love peanut butter!

  • 5
    mixed creams

    Posted by Laura on 16th Feb 2019

    Got a custom box of my son's favorite milk chocolate creams and he said they were the best he's every had. This will be our yearly Valentine's Day tradition.

  • 5

    Posted by Tracy on 12th Feb 2019

    These chocolates are fantastic! I am super picky when it comes to chocolate creams. These are some of the best I have ever had. Plus packaging was done extremely well and candy came super fast. Every piece I have eaten (and that’s a lot) has been delicious! And they are a nice big size as well. I am so happy I stumbled upon their website. I will be a regular customer!!

  • 5
    carmel cream toffee and other

    Posted by Kathleen on 4th Feb 2019

    Excellent flavors--very delicious

  • 5

    Posted by Cindy on 12th Jan 2019

    Oh my gosh! The best. Ordered milk chocolate creams for mom she said the strawberry cream was fantastic real strawberry flavor. Ordered dark chocolate caramel assortment for dad. Soft caramel with marshmallow and dark chocolate was my sinful pleasure. I loved that you could pick your own flavors for the assortment. Will order again next holiday.