null Your SEO optimized title

Full Create a box

(39 reviews) Write a Review
Calculated at Checkout

Mrs Cavanaugh's "create a box" is the easiest way to customize your own box, filled with chocolates you love the most! The box will be evenly split amongst the chocolates you select. Depending on the variety, there are approximately 18-26 chocolates per pound.

To see our complete list of available chocolates, please Click Here


Caramel, Almond, Chocolate Dipped (Gregory) Select pecans blended with slow cooked caramel smothered in chocolate

Caramel, Cashew (Trinidad) Roasted cashew nuts coated with slow cooked caramel and chocolate

Caramel, Chocolate Dipped Slow cooked caramelized caramel smothered in chocolate

Caramel, Coconut, Chocolate Dipped (Brady) Layered macaroon coconut and caramel smothered in chocolate

Caramel, Marshmallow, Chocolate Dipped (Brittany) Our layered marshmallow and caramel smothered in chocolate

Caramel, Pecan Turtle (Cavalier) Everyone's favorite chewy caramel placed on a bed of select pecans smothered in chocolate - Full boxes are available in "Boxed Chocolates"

Caramel, Pecan, Chocolate Dipped (Helen) Select pecans blended with slow cooked caramel smothered in chocolate 

Caramel, Sea Salt, Chocolate Dipped Slow cooked caramel coated in chocolate and lightly sprinkled with Sea Salt

Caramel, Stand-up (un-dipped) Slow cooked caramel

Cherry Cordials Select maraschino cherries, juice smothered by chocolate – Full boxes of this item are available in the “Boxed Chocolates” section

Cluster, Almond Select roasted almonds blended with chocolate

Cluster, Brazil Brazil nuts smothered in chocolate

Cluster, Cashew Roasted cashews smothered in chocolate

Cluster, Coconut (Haystack) Toasted coconut blended with chocolate

Cluster, Macadamia Macadamia nuts blended with chocolate

Cluster, Macadamia Nut and Coconut (Aloha) Macadamia nuts and toasted coconut with chocolate

Cluster, Peanut Roasted Spanish peanuts blended with chocolate

Cluster, Pecan Select pecans blended with chocolate

Coconut Mounds Soft smooth coconut center dipped in chocolate

Crème, Apricot Silky smooth apricot flavored cream smothered in chocolate – Made with real fruit!

Crème, Black Walnut Delicious cream & black walnuts smothered in chocolate

Crème, Cherry Almond Cream, maraschino cherries, and diced almonds smothered in chocolate

Crème, Chocolate Fudge Silky smooth chocolate cream and diced pecans smothered in chocolate

Crème, Chocolate Silky smooth chocolate cream smothered in chocolate

Crème, Chocolate-Vanilla-Strawberry (Opera) Chocolate, Vanilla, and Strawberry Neapolitan Cream smothered in chocolate 

Crème, French Mint Mint flavored buttercream double dipped in milk and dark chocolate

Crème, Key Lime Lime flavored cream smothered in chocolate

Crème, Lemon Custard Fresh squeezed lemon added to our cream smothered in chocolate

Crème, Maple Nut Silky smooth maple cream and pecans smothered in chocolate

Crème, Orange Silky smooth orange flavored cream smothered in chocolate

Crème, Penoche Silky smooth cream and select pecans smothered in chocolate

Crème, Raspberry Lemonade Layered lemon and raspberry flavored cream smothered in chocolate

Crème, Raspberry Smooth raspberry cream smothered in chocolate

Crème, Rough Rum Rum fondant center with roasted almonds in chocolate

Crème, Rum (Pollyanna) Rum cream with roasted almonds on the outside of the chocolate

Crème, Rum (Victoria) Silky smooth rum flavored cream smothered in chocolate

Crème, Rum Ball Silky smooth rum flavored cream smothered in chocoalte and topped with pecans

Crème, Strawberry Smooth strawberry cream smothered in chocolate – Made with real fruit!

Crème, Vanilla Delight Silky smooth vanilla flavored cream smothered with toasted coconut and chocolate

Crème, Vanilla Silky smooth vanilla flavored cream smothered in chocolate

Fluff, Marshmallow (Angel) Marshmallow smothered in chocolate

Fluff, Marshmallow and Coconut Marshmallow and coconut smothered in chocolate

Fudgette Delicious fudge center smothered in chocolate

Marzipan Creamy marzipan center smothered in chocolate

Sandwich Mints Green mint chocolate sandwiched between smooth chocolate

Seafoam Honeycomb sweet crunch smothered in chocolate

Smore Graham Cracker and marshmallow smothered in chocolate

Toffee Nut Real butter toffee smothered in chocolate and roasted almonds

Toffee Real butter toffee smothered in chocolate

Toffee, Almond Crunch

Truffle, Chocolate Melt in your mouth truffle

Truffle, Mint (Mindy) Bavarian mint flavored chocolate center smothered in chocolate - Full boxes of this item are available - Click Here

Truffle, Orange (Adrianne) Orange chocolate truffle

Truffle, Peanut Butter Peanut butter chocolate center smothered in chocolate

Truffle, Raspberry Raspberry chocolate truffle

39 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    the lemon cream milk chocolate

    Posted by Paula McGee on 14th Jan 2021

    Wow your chocolate made me so happy my favorite is lemon. I will be ordering more real soon.

  • 5
    Create a box

    Posted by Carol Drew on 25th Dec 2020

    An entire box of my favorite -orange cream-!!!! And just as delicious as I remember. I will defiantly be reordering these, in fact as soon as I finish this review.

  • 5
    Mrs Cavanaugh Delivery

    Posted by Brian F on 18th Oct 2020

    Wanted something for my elderly father. They hadn’t been able to travel to Bountiful since Covid so had this delivered to them in St George. Delivery was great. Father loved it.

  • 5
    Build abox

    Posted by Theresa Cordi on 14th Oct 2020

    We choose to get a 2lb box full of s’mores with milk chocolate. We love them so much! Nothing melted and nice treat in these tough times!

  • 5
    Mrs C's does it right!!

    Posted by Michael Scillia on 10th May 2020

    We found Mrs C's after our local, family-owned shop closed down a few years ago (Nagel's Candy Barn, if anyone from NJ know what I'm talking about) My wife was obsessed with Nagel's Raspberry Creme's. We tried dozens of places to find an equivelent, but could not find a chocolatier who made a respectable creme anywhere. Then I stumbled across Mrs C's on the internet... The pictures looked great, so I gave them a shot... Let me tell you - they exceeded my expectations. We've been going back to Mrs C's for quite a while now. Just about every holiday, and sometimes in between. We try new things each time. Everything we've had is always amazing. My personal new favorite is the "Brittany" - caramel, marshmallow and chocolate. OMG sooooo good. Highly recommend it!! The customer experience/service is top notch too. Mike is super responsive and very helpful too! Mrs. C's for the win!!

  • 4
    Create a box

    Posted by Holly Stone on 28th Apr 2020

    My husband enjoyed this box full of his favorite candy. It was nice to be able to specify what to put in it as he is very picky. The candy was tasty also. Very nice!

  • 5

    Posted by Denise Hamernik on 21st Apr 2020

    As always, crisp toasted coconut covered in rich, smooth delicious milk chocolate. What’s not to love

  • 5
    Love love love

    Posted by Chrissy Hiatt on 17th Apr 2020

    I get an order monthly I love this chocolate ❤️

  • 4
    Caramel,marshmallow,chocolate, oh my!

    Posted by Jennifer on 6th Feb 2020

    How can you go wrong? These are the most delicious I have ever had! Not sharing!

  • 5
    All Dark Marzipan

    Posted by Karen Christensen on 23rd Dec 2019

    No one makes dark chocolate marzipan like Mrs Cavanaugh's ❤️